A recent stash of Auto magazines

It’s incredibly fulfilling when a reader or viewer says they made a vehicle purchase after watching one of my reviews. Knowing my work holds that kind of sway comes with a sense of responsibility—a drive to deliver genuine value to consumers, ultimately boosting the manufacturer’s bottom line too. After all, the auto industry is one I’ve come to love deeply. I’ve got shelves full of car and motorcycle magazines collected over decades—TopGear, Autocar—you name it. I caught this bug from my older cousins, who were always flipping through pages of car reviews and industry updates. Years before YouTube, I devoured every AutoShow I could catch.

But here’s the rub: after all these years immersed in the industry, I’ve got a few bones to pick with how we, as auto journalists, sometimes approach things.

1. The “Cars Are Getting Bigger and Heavier” Gripe

Yes, they are, but let’s consider why. We’re often the first to criticize “noisy cabins” or “cheap materials.” Manufacturers respond by making cars bigger, with roomier interiors and all the insulation and fancy NVH (noise, vibration, harshness) treatments we could ask for—adding weight in the process. Now we get to stretch out on our 14-way adjustable seats, but with that comfort comes extra bulk.

Size comparison 1970 Fiat 500 vs 2022 Fiat 500 (image source: Motoring Middle East)

2. We’re Constantly Complaining

Sure, it’s human nature to nitpick, but our relentless complaints push manufacturers to find solutions that add costs, complexity, and sometimes, unnecessary gadgetry. When industry regulations pile on top, you end up with an avalanche of features that may satisfy the critics but sometimes miss the mark with real-world drivers.

3. Infotainment Woes

“Too many buttons!” we shout. Manufacturers consolidate HVAC and infotainment controls into touchscreens. “Why can’t I just use muscle memory?” we ask. It’s a no-win game, but maybe we could aim to understand the manufacturer’s side rather than react to every tweak in design.

4. Cargo Covers, of All Things

We complain they’re flimsy, so manufacturers make them sturdier. Now we complain they’re too heavy and awkward to store. The poor cargo cover just can’t catch a break.

5. From Bland to Bold

A car looks bland? We critique it. A car’s design takes risks? We call it garish. The balancing act manufacturers play here is enormous, and as journalists, we could give a little more credit to the tightrope they’re walking.

Opel Vectra vs BMW M4

6. Our Obsession with Speed

It’s almost universal: we can’t help but swoon over speed. My wife doesn’t get the hype; she drives responsibly but still ends up with a heavy foot without realizing it. The faster a car goes, the more you need bigger engines, advanced cooling, sophisticated brakes—the works. But then we turn around and pine for the simplicity of a classic Mk1 VW Golf. Go figure.

Modern Classic: 1974 Volkswagen Golf GTI MK1

At the end of the day, we should hold ourselves to a higher standard and review cars through the eyes of a well-informed consumer. By balancing our critiques with a dash of empathy and understanding, we can continue giving value to readers, manufacturers, and the industry at large, while driving genuine progress and consumer-centered innovation.

My two cents!

Leave a Reply

Trending